Understanding Courtroom Terms: What Does Sustained Mean In Court?

If you have never caught a courtroom drama or a real trial on TV, you probably have not heard the words “Sustained!” and “Overruled!” yelled by a judge. 

So, what does sustained mean in court, and why is it such a big deal during a trial? These words might be difficult and puzzling. 

However, they actually fulfill a very significant function in ensuring that the trial remains fair for all parties. 

In this post, I will go over the meaning of the phrase “sustained” in court, the reason why judges say it, and how it applies to both lawyers and witnesses. 

Therefore, if you are interested in knowing this, then don’t stop reading until the very end… 

What Does Sustained Mean In Court?

The term “sustained” in court refers to a situation when a judge indicates that he agrees with the objection made by the lawyer. 

An objection is a situation when a lawyer opines that something which is being said or done during the trial is not fair, is improper, or violates the rules of the court. 

Apart from “sustained” the judge effectively expresses his agreement with the objection and therefore will not continue or will not allow the contested issue. 

Let’s break it down: 

• A lawyer might say, “Objection! That question is leading the witness.” 

• If the judge agrees with that objection, the judge will say “Sustained.” 

• This means the question can’t be answered, and the witness has to stop. 

Let me give you an example. Imagine it is like a referee in a sports match. The referee sees and stops the illegal action. 

To be more precise, if a player commits a foul train, the referee communicates by blowing whistle thus stopping the illegal action. 

In the analogy of a court, the judge can stop the process of the implementation of the injustice by sustaining the objection if the unfair action has been committed in the process of the court. 

The use of the term “sustained” is a way to ensure the protection of the rights of the people in the courtroom. 

Not only does this make everyone treat each other fairly, but it also makes sure the legal rules are followed and that no party goes beyond the boundaries of the law, and thus, the other party is not wronged. 

If the judge finds the evidence presented by the lawyer convincing, then usually after the judges decision to allow an objection, their point must be accepted by the other side. 

When Does A Judge Sustain An Objection?

During a trial, if a judge records that some words or actions of one of the parties violate the rules of a courtroom, he makes a decision to sustain an objection. 

Honestly, the rules are mostly about the way the questions are posed, the evidence that is given, or the behavior of those who are participating during the trial.

Here are common reasons why a judge may sustain an objection: 

1. Leading Question: This is when a lawyer suggests the answer in their question. For example, “You were angry that night, weren’t you?” This isn’t allowed during direct examination. 

2. Hearsay: If a witness tries to talk about what someone else said outside of court, that’s hearsay and often not allowed. 

3. Irrelevant Information: If something being said doesn’t relate to the case, it can be objected to. Judges don’t want to waste time on unrelated facts. 

4. Speculation: If a witness guesses instead of stating what they saw or experienced directly. 

5. Badgering the Witness: If a lawyer is being too aggressive or bullying a witness. 

When a judge hears the objection and agrees, they will say “Sustained.” This means the jury (if there is one) must ignore what was just said, and the conversation will move on. 

It’s all about keeping things fair, clear, and focused on the real facts of the case. Judges use “sustained” to make sure lawyers follow the proper procedures. 

What Happens When An Objection Is Sustained?

When a judge says “Objection sustained,” it means the judge agrees with the lawyer who objected—and something that just happened must stop or be corrected. 

Here’s what usually happens: 

• The witness may be told not to answer the question. 

• The lawyer may have to ask a different question or change the topic. 

• The jury (if present) will be told to ignore what was just said. 

For example, if a lawyer asks, “Did you hear your neighbor say he planned the crime?” and the other lawyer objects, saying it’s hearsay, the judge might say, “Sustained.” The witness can’t answer, and the jury has to pretend they didn’t hear that part. 

Even though it’s hard to un-hear something, judges use instructions like this to help make sure the trial stays fair. 

A sustained objection doesn’t mean someone is in trouble. It simply means the rules weren’t followed, and the judge is correcting that mistake right away. It helps keep the trial orderly, respectful, and focused only on allowed evidence and legal arguments. 

Examples Of An Objection Being Sustained

Let’s look at some simple examples of what it looks like when an objection is sustained: 

Example 1: Leading Question:

• Lawyer: “You were angry when you saw him, right?” 

• Other lawyer: “Objection! Leading the witness.” 

• Judge: “Sustained.” 

The question is not allowed. The lawyer has to rephrase it. 

Example 2: Hearsay:

• Witness: “My friend told me she saw the accident happen.” 

• Lawyer: “Objection! Hearsay.” 

• Judge: “Sustained.” 

The witness can’t talk about what their friend said. 

Example 3: Irrelevant Question:

• Lawyer: “What’s your favorite movie?” 

• Other lawyer: “Objection! Irrelevant.” 

• Judge: “Sustained.” 

The question doesn’t relate to the case, so it’s not allowed. 

These examples show how judges step in to keep things fair and focused on the truth. 

What Does Overruled Mean In Court?

“Overruled” is the opposite of “sustained.” When a lawyer objects during a trial, and the judge disagrees with the objection, the judge will say “Overruled.” This means the question or action can continue, and the person can keep speaking or answering.

Let’s say a lawyer says, “Objection, that’s hearsay!” If the judge thinks the statement doesn’t break the rules, they’ll say “Overruled.” In that case, the witness can go ahead and answer the question. 

Here are a few more examples:

Example 1:

• Lawyer: “Objection! That’s leading.” 

• Judge: “Overruled.” 

The judge believes the question is fine and doesn’t suggest an answer. 

Example 2: 

• Lawyer: “Objection! The question is irrelevant.” 

• Judge: “Overruled.” 

The judge thinks the question does matter to the case. 

Just like with “sustained,” a judge uses “overruled” to keep things fair—but in this case, they are allowing something to continue. They are saying, “No, I don’t agree with the objection. Keep going.” 

It’s important to remember that just because an objection is overruled doesn’t mean it was a bad objection. It just means the judge didn’t find a good enough reason to stop what was happening. 

Both “sustained” and “overruled” are part of the legal process and help judges keep control of the courtroom. 

Your Exclusive Rights In Court Trials

Whenever you are involved in a court case in any capacity—be it as a witness, a party, or even just as a spectator—you are entitled to a fair trial.

The terms like “sustained”, “overruled” might seem to be some sort of legal jargon, but they are the means judges use in their work in order to ensure that all participants in the court understand the rules and that the trial is fair for everyone.

Being familiar with courtroom language such as “What does sustained mean in court?” makes you able to keep up with the situation and detect the way the legal process operates. It also makes you more understanding of the structure and flow in the courtroom during a trial. 

Grasping the precise time and the reasons for a judge to utter the words “sustained” or “overruled” will increase your self-confidence greatly in the event that you will be required to participate in some legal matter. 

In case you ever become puzzled with the vocabulary of the court, feel free to ask your lawyer anything you do not understand. They are willing to help and support you at all times in your journey. 

In conclusion, the justice system is designed to guarantee the rights of everyone—your rights, particularly—and knowing the language of judges is just a minor endeavor to be sure these rights are respected and upheld in court. 

Read Also:

• When Will A Warrant Be Issued After You Fail to Pay Child Support?
• Is It Illegal To Drive Barefoot? Know Your Rights When Driving a Car
• Joint Tenants vs Tenants in Common: Know the Law to Know Your Rights!